individual honors (since 1994) 

all-conference and naia all-america players 

Year  Player  All-Conference  All-America 
1994-95  Lance Stachler  1st team  Honorable Mention 
x  Galen Mast   3rd team  x 
1995-96  Brodie Garber  2nd team  x 
1996-97  Jeff Shepherd  1st team  Honorable Mention 
x  Brodie Garber  2nd team  x 
x  Matt Eberly  3rd team  x 
x  Gabe LaGrange  3rd team  x 
1997-98  Gabe LaGrange  1st team  Honorable Mention 
x  Jeff Shepherd  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
1998-99  Jeff Shepherd  Player of the Year  1st team 
x  Gabe LaGrange  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Brodie Garber  3rd team  x 
x  Matt Eberly  3rd team  x 
1999-00  Gabe LaGrange  1st team  1st team 
x  David Porter  2nd team  x 
x  Brodie Garber  3rd team  x 
x  Brandon Holler  3rd team  x 
2000-01  David Porter  Player of the Year  1st team 
2001-02  David Porter  Player of the Year  1st team 
x  Brett Snodgrass  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Adam Hill  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
2002-03  Adam Hill  Co-Player of the Year  1st team 
x  Ryan Thwaits  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Justin Riegsecker  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Chase Verba  3rd team  x 
2003-04  Ryan Thwaits  1st team  3rd team 
x  Derek Yoder  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Chase Verba  3rd team  x 
x  Steve Snider  Honorable Mention   x 
2004-05  Alex Kock  Player of the Year  2nd team 
x  Kyle Ganton  2nd team  Honorable Mention 
x  Doug Sheckler  3rd team  x 
x  Chase Verba  Honorable Mention  x 
x  Steve Snider  Honorable Mention  x 
2005-06  Alex Kock  Co-Player of the Year  1st team 
x  Kyle Ganton  2nd team  2nd team 
x  Doug Sheckler  3rd Team  x 
x  Chase Verba  Honorable Mention  x 
x  Steve Snider  Honorable Mention  x 
2006-07  Alex Kock  Player of the Year  Nat'l POY; 1st team 
x  Kyle Ganton  1st team  2nd team 
x  Doug Sheckler  3rd team  x 
x  Jared Yoder  Honorable Mention  x 
2007-08  Kyle Benge  3rd team  x 
x  Kevin Kyle  3rd team  x 
x  Doug Sheckler  Player of the Year  1st team 
x  Tyler Shively  All-Newcomer Team  x 
2008-09  Kyle Benge  2nd team  x 
x  Kevin Kyle  3rd team  x 
x  Tyler Shively  3rd team  x 
2009-10  Kellen Zawadzki  2nd team  x 
x  Tyler Shively  3rd team  x 
x  Luke Smith  Honorable Mention  x 
2010-11 Kellen Zawadzki 1st team Honorable Mention
  Tyler Shively 2nd team  
  Caleb Kennedy Honorable Mention  
  Shane Merryman All-Newcomer Team  
2011-12 Caleb Kennedy Player of the Year 1st Team
  Shane Merryman 3rd Team  
  Ryan Boester All-Newcomer Team  
2012-13 Shane Merryman 1st Team 3rd Team