individual honors (since 1994) 

all-conference and naia all-america players 

Year Player All-Conference All-America
1994-95 Lance Stachler 1st team Honorable Mention
x Galen Mast  3rd team x
1995-96 Brodie Garber 2nd team x
1996-97 Jeff Shepherd 1st team Honorable Mention
x Brodie Garber 2nd team x
x Matt Eberly 3rd team x
x Gabe LaGrange 3rd team x
1997-98 Gabe LaGrange 1st team Honorable Mention
x Jeff Shepherd 2nd team Honorable Mention
1998-99 Jeff Shepherd Player of the Year 1st team
x Gabe LaGrange 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Brodie Garber 3rd team x
x Matt Eberly 3rd team x
1999-00 Gabe LaGrange 1st team 1st team
x David Porter 2nd team x
x Brodie Garber 3rd team x
x Brandon Holler 3rd team x
2000-01 David Porter Player of the Year 1st team
2001-02 David Porter Player of the Year 1st team
x Brett Snodgrass 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Adam Hill 2nd team Honorable Mention
2002-03 Adam Hill Co-Player of the Year 1st team
x Ryan Thwaits 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Justin Riegsecker 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Chase Verba 3rd team x
2003-04 Ryan Thwaits 1st team 3rd team
x Derek Yoder 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Chase Verba 3rd team x
x Steve Snider Honorable Mention  x
2004-05 Alex Kock Player of the Year 2nd team
x Kyle Ganton 2nd team Honorable Mention
x Doug Sheckler 3rd team x
x Chase Verba Honorable Mention x
x Steve Snider Honorable Mention x
2005-06 Alex Kock Co-Player of the Year 1st team
x Kyle Ganton 2nd team 2nd team
x Doug Sheckler 3rd Team x
x Chase Verba Honorable Mention x
x Steve Snider Honorable Mention x
2006-07 Alex Kock Player of the Year Nat'l POY; 1st team
x Kyle Ganton 1st team 2nd team
x Doug Sheckler 3rd team x
x Jared Yoder Honorable Mention x
2007-08 Kyle Benge 3rd team x
x Kevin Kyle 3rd team x
x Doug Sheckler Player of the Year 1st team
x Tyler Shively All-Newcomer Team x
2008-09 Kyle Benge 2nd team x
x Kevin Kyle 3rd team x
x Tyler Shively 3rd team x
2009-10 Kellen Zawadzki 2nd team x
x Tyler Shively 3rd team x
x Luke Smith Honorable Mention x
2010-11 Kellen Zawadzki 1st team Honorable Mention
  Tyler Shively 2nd team  
  Caleb Kennedy Honorable Mention  
  Shane Merryman All-Newcomer Team  
2011-12 Caleb Kennedy Player of the Year 1st Team
  Shane Merryman 3rd Team  
  Ryan Boester All-Newcomer Team  
2012-13 Shane Merryman 1st Team 3rd Team
2013-14 Shane Merryman 1st Team 2nd Team
  Derek Hinen 3rd Team; All-Newcomer Team  
  TJ Short Honorable Mention