MCC/Crossroads All-Conference 

  Thad Abel   1977, 1978
  Shea Beauchamp   2016 (HM), 2017
  Glenn Berggoetz   1988
  Jason Boldt   1996
  Matt Brumbaugh   1987, 1988, 1989
  Mike Barton   1970
  Jerry Blastic   1970, 1971, 1972
  Mitch Bowers   2010, 2011
  Justin Branock   2010 (HM)
  Lance Chrisman   1990, 1991, 1992
  Josh Clark     2004
  Dalton Combs   2016, 2017
  Ryan Crabb   1998
  Mike Crowley   2014, 2015, 2017 (HM)
  Hank DeHaven   1997
  Tim Dell   1988
  Andrew Drummond    2007, 2009, 2010
  Chuck Fowler   1975, 1976
  Thad Frame   2005, 2007
  Korey Grow   2006, 2007, 2008
  Dave Goodmiller   1979, 1980
  Buell Gonzales   1973
  Brock Gower   2016 (HM)
  Jarod Hammel   2010 (HM)
  Rob Harness   1979
  Dylan Henricks    2017 (HM)
  Fred Herron   1970
  Blake Hohlbein   2015 (HM)
  Jeff Hubner   1972
  Andy Janzen   2006  
  Coley Johnson   1974
  Tom Johnson   1987
  Austan Kas   2008
  Jerry Kaufman   2000, 2001
  Shawn Kauzlick   1998
  Joel Kennedy   2004
  Brian Kirschbaum    2012
  Russ Lawson   1988, 1991
  Mark LeBeau   2002, 2003
  Sean Lewis   1991
  Heath Luther   1999, 2000, 2001
  Gerry Mason   1987, 1989
  DJ Moore   2017
  Dave Neuenschwander   1987
  Don Neuenschwander   1970, 1971, 1972
  Doug Neuenschwander   1974, 1975, 1976, 1977
  Andy Nucci   2000
  Keith Oszuszik   1977, 1978, 1979
  Mark Parker   1975, 1976, 1977, 1978
  Brian Porter   2004, 2005
  Kent Pyle   1979, 1980
  Alex Rinearson   2008
  Dan Richards   1980
  Edwin Rodriquez   2009
  Adam Roser   2017
  Andy Roser   2017 (HM)
  Steve Rudd   1990
  Eric Schultz   2010, 2011, 2012
  Todd Sherman   1987
  Mason Shinabery   2017
  Greg Slee   2003, 2004
  Craig Sloan   1996, 1998
  Brian Smith   1971, 1972, 1973
  Stan Speheger      1975, 1976, 1977, 1978
  Terry Strahm    1973
  Neil Stinson   2000, 2001
  Deron Swanson   1996
  Drew Taylor   2007, 2009
  Darren Tecklenburg   1987, 1988, 1989
  Norm Thompson   1975, 1976
  Gerry Tilker   1970, 1971, 1972
  Jamar Weaver   2016 (HM)
  Todd Weeks   1996
  Scott Weiss   1978
  Tom Wood   1971
  Robin Wright   1979, 1980
  Tanner Wyse   2017
  Kyle Zerfas   2015
  Terry Zorger   1972


MCC/Crossroads Golden Glove Award

  Blake Ayers   2011, 2012
  Shea Beauchamp   2016
  Keith Benbow   2007
  Adam Christner   2011, 2012, 2013
  Dalton Combs   2016
  Mike Crowley   2015, 2017
  Austin Drummond   2014
  Thad Frame   2008
  Travis Frantz   2009
  Dylan Henricks   2017
  Austan Kas   2007, 2008
  Jordan Klopfenstein   2012
  Josh Lanphier   2013
  TJ Lindstrand   2015
  Adam Roser   2016
  Andy Roser   2017
  Eric Schultz   2012
  Ryan Shell   2010
  Drew Taylor   2007


NAIA All-District/Regional

  Jason Boldt   1996
  Matt Brumbaugh   1988, 1989
  Lance Chrisman   1992
  Tim Dell   1988
  Andrew Drummond   2007
  Chuck Fowler   1974, 1976
  Thad Frame   2007
  Dave Goodmiller   1980
  Korey Grow     2007
  Rob Harness   1979
  Jerry Kaufman   2001
  Russ Lawson   1991
  Sean Lewis   1991
  Heath Luther   1999, 2000, 2001
  Don Neuenschwander   1972
  Doug Neuenschwander   1974, 1975, 1976, 1977
  Andy Nucci   2000
  Keith Oszuszik   1977, 1978, 1979
  Mark Parker   1977, 1978
  Brian Porter   2004
  Alex Rinearson   2008
  Frank Rohrs 1974
  Todd Sherman 1987
  Greg Slee   2003, 2004
  Craig Sloan   1996, 1998
  Stan Speheger   1976, 1977
  Neil Stinson   2000, 2001
  Darren Tecklenburg   1989, 1990
  Gerry Tilker   1971, 1972
  Terry Zorger   1972


NAIA Regional Golden Glove Award

  Austan Kas   2007, 2008


NAIA All-America Scholar Athlete

  Ryan Bethel   2017
  Russ Degitz   2002
  Tim Dell   1988
  Tyson Dietrich   2017
  Travis Frantz   2010, 2011
  Jamon Hammel   2012, 2013
  Jarod Hammel   2009, 2010
  Jerry Kaufman   2001
  Josh Lanphier   2012, 2013
  Mark Parker   1978
  Kent Pyle   1980
  Ty Sherman   1991
  Craig Sloan   1998
  Brice Urschel   2015
  Jamar Weaver   2017
  Tanner Wyse   2015, 2016


NAIA All-America

  Jason Boldt   1996
  Andrew Drummond   2010 (HM)
  Jerry Kaufman     2001
  Sean Lewis   1991
  Andy Nucci   2000
  Mark Parker   1978
  Brian Porter   2004 (HM)
  Greg Slee    2003, 2004 (HM)
  Craig Sloan    1996
  Neil Stinson   2000, 2001
  Darren Tecklenburg   1989
  Terry Zorger   1972
  Heath Luther   1999, 2000, 2001


Foresters in Professional Baseball

  Mike Dafforn   Philadelphia   1988
  Tim Dell   Philadelphia   1988
  Jim Lawson   Oakland   1988
  Heath Luther   Anaheim   2001
  Doug Neuenschwander   Cincinnati   1977
  Mark Parker   Chicago Cubs   1978
  Greg Slee   Seattle   2004
  Terry Zorger   Los Angeles   1972