NAIA All-America 

  Nick Johnson   2008
  John Ngure   1999, 2000, 2001

 

NAIA All-America Scholar Athletes

  Michael Bowman   2015, 2016
  Chris Beuhrer   2002, 2003
  Greg Byrum   2000, 2001
  Luke Diehl     2008, 2009
  Rick Hammer   2001, 2002
  Tyler Herber   2014, 2015
  Nick Johnson   2007, 2008
  Stephen Kays   2015
  Josh McIntyre   2012
  Brian Menzie   2013, 2014
  Codi Wiersema   2016
  Lance Wood   2011, 2012

 

NAIA All-Region

  Cody Hannie   2004
  Nick Johnson   2006, 2007
  John Ngure   2001, 2002
  John Njeri   2007
  Cameron Norris   2001
  Tobias Sauter   2007

 

MCC/Crossroads All-Conference

  Rick Hammer   1998
  Cody Hannie   2003, 2004
  Joseph Herber   2008, 2009, 2010
  Tyler Herber    2012, 2013
  Nick Johnson   2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
  Dan Lindbloom   2006, 2007, 2008, 2009
  Cameronn Norris   2001
  Alec Rosario   2011
  Joseph Waithira   2003, 2004
  Lance Wood   2011
  Tom King, Coach of the Year   2003, 2007, 2008, 2011