On the men’s soccer field, the Foresters have consistently produced all-conference players. Thirty-eight Foresters have earned this distinction. Rick Cook and Greg Fiedler are the only Foresters to appear on the all-conference team in each of their four seasons at Huntington University.

Seven Foresters — Fiedler, Joe Beah, Rick Cook, Patrick Dangawali, Courtney Hamiltion, Bai Kabia and John Labor — have been recognized at the national level as NAIA All-Americans. Labor earned this honor thrice during the time he donned a Forester jersey.