NAIA All-America

  Dirk Rehbeg   1993-94
  Shail Galada   1994-95
  Vlad Khudziy   2010-11 (HM), 2011-12 (2nd)


NAIA All-American Scholar Athletes

  Jameel Brenneman   2011, 2012
  Jonathan Brenneman   2011, 2012
  Matt Cable    2008, 2009
  Jacob Cross   2015
  Brandon Curtis   2004, 2005
  Ben Eggleston   2002, 2003
  Dean Groetzinger   1998
  Vlad Khudziy   2013, 2014
  Trevor Lee     1998
  Jacob MIles   2001, 2002
  Adam Widener   2007


All-Conference

  Ron Baker   1966
  Rich Blake   1979, 1980
  Michael Christner   2002
  Jeff Clements   1990, 1991, 1992
  Hamish Dunn   1995
  Shail Galada   1994, 1995
  Ron Gamble   1984
  Bob Hull   1974, 1976
  Jose Hungria   2010, 2013
  Diego Inurritegui   2013, 2014
  Cornelius Jordan   1988
  Dana Karlson   1989
  Vlad Khudziy   2010, 2011, 2012, 2013
  Peter Kitchen   1991, 1992, 1993, 1994
  Barry Leiter   1968
  Peter Magnusson   1995
  Rodrigo Manzo   2016
  Bryan McDaniel   1999
  Jacob Miles   2000, 2001
  Tyler Moore   2006, 2007
  Andy Perry   1989, 1990, 1991, 1992
  Ignacio Poncio   2015, 2016
  Andre Porritt   1992
  Dirk Rehberg   1993
  Frederico Rodriquez   1998
  Troy Sands   1999
  Juan Segovia   1989
  Kachinga Sinkala   2002
  Roger Skinner   1961, 1962, 1963, 1964
  Joseph Straznicky   2013, 2014, 2015
  David Taylor   2000
  Matt Taylor   1998, 2000
  Nate Taylor   1999
  Augusto Velez   2010, 2011
  Gonzalo Vivas   2007, 2008, 2009


Conference Coach of the Year

  Mark Fairchild   1989, 1991, 1992
  Roger Ferguson   2010