NAIA All-American

  Amy Bechtel   1998
  1999
  2000
  Honorable Mention
  First Team
  First Team
  Courtney Beerbower   2010   Honorable Mention
  Amy Berry   2006
  2007
  Honorable Mention
  Third Team
  Crissy Collins   2002   Third Team
  Lauren Davenport   2009   Third Team
  Kelsey Green   2011
  2012
  Honorable Mention
  Third Team
  Joanne Miller   1992
  1993
  Honorable Mention
  Honorable Mention
  Miranda Palmer   2015
  2016
  2017
  Honorable Mention
  Second Team
  First Team
  Cindy Schweikhardt   1993
  1994
  Second Team
  Honorable Mention
  Pazia Speed   2014   Second Team
  Hedi Wright   1995   Honorable Mention


NCCAA All-America

  Michelle Harter   1988
  1989
  1990
  First Team
  Second Team
  First Team
  Joy Gamble   1990   First Team
  Tina Hinrichsen   1992   Second Team
  Joanne Green   1991
  1992
  1993
  Second Team
  First Team
  First Team
  Chanda Reeves   1990    Second Team
  Cindy Schweikhardt   1993   First Team
  Jeanne Wuest   1987   First Team


NAIA All-America Scholar Athlete

  Mindy Adams   2000, 2001
  Brittney Bateman   2009, 2010
  Betsey Bean   2005, 2006
  Amy Bechtel   1999, 2000
  Amber Bender   1998, 1999
  Jaclene Bonnema   2015, 2016
  Wendy Brittenham   1998, 1999
  Jessah Brumbaugh   2007
  Katie Crandall   2008
  Lauren Davenport   2008, 2009
  Gina Eisenhut   2017
  Beth Emerich   1990 (NCCAA)
  Annie Feldpausch   2007
  Joy Gamble   1990 (NCCCAA)
  Nichole Gill    1998
  Kelsey Green   2011, 2012
  Jamie Grogg   2005
  Hailey Krewald   2017
  Lauren Meese   2013
  Joanne Miller   1992, 1993 (NAIA, NCCAA)
  Holly Newman   1998, 1999
  Miranda Palmer   2016, 2017
  Chanda Reeves   1990 (NCCAA)
  Allyson Trout   2016, 2017
  Amy Wanemacher   2007


All-Conference

  Lane Allen   2004   Third Team
  Amy Becthel   1998
  1999
  2000
  First Team
 First Team, Co-Player of the Year
  First Team
  Courtney Baker   2009
  2010
  First Team
  First Team
  Jill Beers   1989   First Team
  Christina Butts   1999   Second Team
  Crissy Collins   2001
  2002
  Second Team
  First Team
  Lauren Davenport   2008
  2009
  Second Team
  First Team
  Liesl Davenport   2012   Freshman of the Year
  Jenna Donaldson   2007
  2008
  2009
  2010
  Newcomer of the Year
  Honorable Mention
  Honorable Mention
  Second Team
  Joy Gamble   1990   First Team
  Nichole Gill   1997   Second Team
  Sarah Gordon   2001
  2003
  Third Team
  Second Team
  Kelsey Green   2011
  2012
  First Team
  First Team
  Michelle Harter   1987
  1988
  1989
  1990
  First Team
  First Team
  First Team
  First Team
  Shelly Hebb   1989   First Team
  Angel Hershberger   1993   First Team
  Kim Hickman   1991   First Team
  Tina Hinrichsen   1991
  1992
  First Team
  First Team
  Heidi Hosler   1991   First Team
  Kelsey Hubble   2016   Honorable Mention
  Amy Kramer   2011   All-Freshmen Team
  Lauren Meese   2010
  2012
  Freshman of the Year
  Second Team
  Bonnie Mevis   1987   First Team
  Joanne Miller   1991
  1992
  1993
  First Team
  First Team
  First Team
  Sarah Miller   2009
  2010
  2011
  2013
  All-Newcomer Team
  Second Team
  Second Team
  Second Team
  Miranda Palmer   2014
  2015
  2016
  2017
  All-Freshmen Team
  First Team
  First Team
  First Team, Player of the Year
  Jessica Ramey   2004
  2005
  Third Team
  Second Team
  Amelia Recker   2013
  2014
  2015
  2016
  All-Freshmen Team
  Second Team
  Second Team
  Second Team
  Chanda Reeves   1988
  1990
  First Team
  First Team
  Cindy Schweikhardt   1992
  1993
  1994
  First Team
  First Team
  First Team
  Pazia Speed   2011
  2012
  2013
  All-Freshmen Team
  Honorable Mention
  First Team
  Allyson Trout   2017   Honorable Mention
  Heidi Wright   1994
  1995
  First Team
  First Team
  Jeanne Wuest   1987   First Team


Conference Coach of the Year

  Lori Culler   1987, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 98, 2011, 14