Members of the Huntington University women’s soccer team have been awarded at the national and conference levels for their efforts on the field. Seventeen players appeared on the all-conference team during their time in a Forester jersey. As a freshman, in 2005, Sarah Kaufman garnered honorable mention honors on the list of NAIA All-Americans.

Tom Datema and Ryan Burgher were named conference coaches of the year in 2002 and 2010, respectively.