NAIA All-America

  Sarah Kaufman   2005   Honorable Mention
  Matéa Knispel   2017   Honorable Mention


NAIA All-America Scholar Athletes

  Erin Abbey   2001, 2002
  Robyn Althoff   2005, 2006
  Elizabeth Ballard   2002
  Joy Bamford   2004, 2005
  MaKayla Barrantes   2017
  Kristyn Bollig   2003
  Shelly Bradbury   2010, 2011
  Randee Bushnell   2011
  Brittany Carlson   2009, 2010
  Paige Coolman   2016
  Leah Cressman   2008, 2009
  Kaityln Dremen   2013, 2014
  Elizabeth Ellis   2014
  Abigail Field   2017
  Kara Fultz   2004, 2005
  Tessy Geiss   2017
  Ashley Gonterman   2005, 2006
  Becca Grimes   2014, 2015
  Michelle Hawthorne   2011
  Amber Hirschy   2002, 2003
  Hannah Kaufman   2005, 2006
  Audra Klopfenstein   2016, 2017
  Matéa Knispel   2017
  Olivia Knispel   2015, 2016
  Blaire Koomler   2017
  Alyssa Krause   2012, 2013
  Jessica Krause   2012, 2013
  Rachel Mathews   2011
  Samantha McCoy   2017
  Bethany McGraw   2008, 2009
  Nicole Pennington   2016
  Kara Shoemaker   2001
  Christi Shook   2004, 2005
  Amy Snider   2013, 2014
  Brandi Spear   2016, 2017
  Rachel TerMarsch   2014, 2015
  Rachel Warrick   2006
  Heidi Zeman   2011


NAIA All-Region

  Erin Abbey   2002   Second Team
  Robyn Althoff   2003   Second Team
  Elizabeth Ballard   2002   Second Team
  Sarah Kaufman   2005   First Team


MCC/Crossroads All-Conference

  Erin Abbey   2002
  Courtney Baker   2012, 2014
  Erin Barclay   2011
  Paige Coolman   2016 (HM), 2017 (HM)
  Sam Cubic   2010, 2013
  Kara Fultz   2003
  Brittany Hartman   2010
  Sara Holtsberry   1998
  Justine Jost   2009
  Hannah Kaufman   2004, 2005
  Matéa Knispel   2015, 2017
  Olivia Knispel   2016
  Sarah Kaufman   2004, 2005, 2007
  Jessica Krause   2013
  Morgan McCloughan   2016 (HM)
  Bethany McGraw   2007, 2008
  Heather O'Keefe   2004
  Kara Shoemaker   2001
  Christi Shook   2002
  Brandi Spear   2017
  Stephanie Spitnale   2008
  Lisa Underwood   2012


Conference Coach of the Year

  Ryan Burgher   2010
  Tom Datema   2002