NAIA All-America Scholar Athletes

  Megan Adams   2011, 2012
  Rachel Boersma   2005
  Stacie Cressman   2013, 2014
  Jessica Deter   2006, 2007
  Kerrie Ecker   2016, 2017
  Kyleigh Gast   2003, 2004
  Constanze Golz   2017
  Becky Harness   2002, 2003
  Joni Holsem   2011, 2012
  Kristen Lahman   2011, 2012
  Haley Neiderhiser   2011, 2012
  Brooke Owens   2000, 2001
  Ashley Scally   2007
  Maria Schrock   1998
  Aleksandra Spasic   2012, 2013
  Katie Sprunger   2006, 2007
  Dana Starks   2002
  Lauren Sunderman   2001, 2012
  Katie Turner   2002, 2003
  Erin Van Kampen   2017
  Lindsey Weber   2002, 2003
  Kyla Zartman   2007, 2008


All-Conference

  Raelyn Althoff   2006, 2007, 2008, 2009
  Morgan Bemisderfer   2014, 2015, 2016
  Meg Dolde   2017
  Constanze Golz   2014, 2015, 2016, 2017
  Becky Harness   2000, 2003
  Cassie Kasicki   2012, 2013
  Haley Neiderhiser   2008, 2009, 2010, 2011
  Janine Senanayake   1999, 2000
  Stephanie Strong   2005, 2006, 2007, 2008


Conference Coach of the Year

  Gary Turner   2006